Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Brendan
12 Jan, 2006

PALGN's 2005 Reader Game of the Year awards

PALGN Feature | You all have a great taste in games. Also, competition winners announced inside.
Back in late December, we asked you readers to complete a little survey, in order to help us out with our Game of the Year awards. Well, we have already shared our opinions, where Resident Evil 4 took out the big honour. It's time we shared yours, too. Just how right were we? Were we even right at all, or were were completely off the mark? The results seem a bit mixed, to say the least. Oh, curious to see if you were one of the lucky competition winners? Scroll down to read who the lucky winners are.

GBA Game of the Year for 2005
5. The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap
4. Gunstar: Future Heroes
3. Wario Ware: Twisted!
2. Mario Tennis: Advance Tour
1. Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones
D Intelligent Systems | P Nintendo
PALGN Review: GBA

It's clear that Nintendo are keen to push the Fire Emblem series out of Japan, with two GBA titles and a GCN game within the last two years. About time - as you readers have indicated, you guys absolutely adore Fire Emblem - especially the latest GBA effort, The Sacred Stones, which now has the 'honour' of being your GBA game of the year. This game is no different to the rest of the games in the series, still relying on a terrific, branching story and fantastic turn based strategy battles. The Sacred Stones pushes the little Game Boy Advance to the limit, with some of the best visuals seen out of the tiny screen, and sounds which aren't justified by those little speakers. It beat out a pretty strong array of competitors, such as our GBA favourite, Ware Ware: Twisted!, among others. The Minish Cap was somewhat of a funny one, with release dates in 2004 and 2005, depending on your territory - but either way, Fire Emblem got the job done.

...


PSP Game of the Year for 2005
5. Ridge Racer
4. Wipeout Pure
3. Burnout: Legends
2. Lumines
1. Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories
D Namco | P Namco
PALGN Review: PSP

The PSP hasn't had the great start that Sony might of hoped for, but it still has its fair share of quality games - most of them involving some sort of racing. Places 5-3 in your voting were all out and out racing games, while the top spot at least has an extensive amount of driving in it. Oh well - we're definitely proud at you guys for voting the fantastic Lumines into second place, though. But, the little guy was always going to have a tough time against the might of Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories, and, in this case, it came off second best. Liberty City Stories isn't the most inventive game in the series, nor is it the strongest. But, it does bring players back to Liberty City, with a new story and array of brand new missions to play. And, it does all this on a handheld console, making it that much more impressive. Great work, Rockstar.

...


NDS Game of the Year for 2005
5. Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow
4. Animal Crossing: Wild World
3. Advance Wars: Dual Strike
2. Nintendogs
1. Mario Kart DS
D Nintendo | P Nintendo
PALGN Review: NDS

Nintendo DS owners have been spoilt for choice towards the end of 2005, regardless of various games suffering annoying delays to PAL regions. You readers have come up with a top 5 full of quality games - and to not even include puzzling powerhouse Meteos just shows you how good the DS line-up is right now. Like us though, you fell for sentimental favourite Mario Kart DS. It's 'just-one-more-go' factor, perfect handling, great online and offline multiplayer, and massive array of grand prix races made it your favourite NDS game of the year. Not even those pesky snakers online could make you put down the DS (although, admit it - you've turned the console off at least once when you've lost the race, haven't you?). Mario Kart DS just topped off a fantastic year from the DS, and we can expect more in 2006.

...


GCN Game of the Year for 2005
5. Killer7
4. Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance
3. Donkey Kong: Jungle Beat
2. The Legend of Zelda: Four Swords Adventures
1. Resident Evil 4
D Capcom Production Studio 4 | P Capcom
PALGN Reviews: GCN, PS2

Well, who didn't see this coming? Resident Evil 4 won the reader's GCN Game of the Year vote by the most astronomical of margins, with even the second placed The Legend of Zelda: Four Swords Adventure left far, far, FAR behind. After writing so many blurbs spurting out various superlatives to describe Resident Evil 4 over the past week, we think we've finally ran out of ways to say how good it is. If you haven't, just buy the damn thing already.

...


Xbox Game of the Year for 2005
5. Forza Motorsport
4. Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory
3. Burnout: Revenge
2. Jade Empire
1. Half Life 2
D Valve | P Vivendi
PALGN Review: Xbox

This was a close one, with not a whole lot seperating the top five games - 2, 3 and 4 were especially close. Our pick, Burnout: Revenge, wasn't as radical as we thought it might of been either, considering you all managed to vote it into third place. However, it was Half Life 2 which came out on top. Deservably so too, considering it is one of the absolutely best first-person shooter experiences one can have. In fact, it's arguably the best single-player FPS ever made. It's not particularly innovative, but it improves on the original Half Life in every possible way. The story is captivating. The controls are sublime. The graphics are sensational. Oh, and then there's the nifty little addition of the gravity gun, which allows you to pick up whatever piece of a equipment, be it a piece of wood or a saw blade, and fling them at the enemies in order to cause a whole lot of carnage. Half Life 2 - a most worthy winner for your Xbox Game of the Year.

...


PC Game of the Year for 2005
5. The Movies
4. Call of Duty 2
3. Civilization IV
2. Battlefield 2
1. F.E.A.R.
D Monolith | P Vivendi
PALGN Review: PC

There was some real quality on the PC this year, so picking a winner was always going to be tough. Call of Duty 2, Civilization IV and Battlefield 2 are all terrific sequels - but in the end, it was the new game, F.E.A.R. that caught your attention. Pushing a horror aspect, F.E.A.R. was always just a littttttle bit different. Noises in the distance, caused by something unseen. Radio static. Brief spots of slow down, accompanied by a loss of control and radio static, to make you uneasy. People thought to be dead appearing on screen, then disintergrating into dust. Oh, and then there's the fact that the big bad is a little girl, complete with red dress. The whole thing is a bit wacky - but, that's why we all love it so much. Combine this unique and unsettling atmosphere with all the other standard requirements of a great first person shooter - brilliant artificial intelligence, fun multiplayer and a captivating story - and it's not hard to see why you voted First Encounter Assault Recon as your PC game of the year. Now if only they didn't put an oxymoron in the title...

...


PS2 Game of the Year for 2005
5. Burnout: Revenge
4. Gran Turismo 4
3. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (PS2)
2. God of War
1. Resident Evil 4
D Capcom Production Studio 4 | P Capcom
PALGN Reviews: GCN, PS2

We're actually quite surprised by the complete lack of Devil May Cry 3: Dante's Awakening in your top five, dear readers. We're also surprised that you put Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater at about the same position we did, too. Still, we aren't quite as surprised with the top two. It was an extremely close battle too, with Resident Evil 4 coming out in front of slasher God of War with just a couple of extra votes. The PS2 version of Capcom's opus has generally played second fiddle to the GCN version, thanks to being released much later, weaker controls, down-tuned visuals, and the fact that the PS2 has a much stronger 2005 line up than the GCN, meaning it doesn't quite stand out as much. Still, Resident Evil 4 is still an utterly superb game - it even sports a few rather nifty extras over its older GCN brother. We cannot really fault your choice here at all, readers.

...


Overall Game of the Year for 2005
5. God of War (PS2)
4. Battlefield 2 (PC)
3. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (PS2)
2. Mario Kart DS (NDS)
1. Resident Evil 4 (GCN/PS2)
D Capcom Production Studio 4 | P Capcom
PALGN Reviews: GCN, PS2

We had some questionable results in our Staff Game of the Year awards - but there is at least one we definitely got right. Like us, you readers thought that Resident Evil 4 was, hands down, the best game released in 2005. It has received endless praise from the gaming media, enthusiasts, and average punters alike - and there's a good reason for it. Resident Evil 4 really is the total package. It has a perfectly judged single player mode, with just the right amount of hours required to knock off the main story and a great learning curve. There's a wide variety of weapons at your disposal, all of which are well-balanced and fun to use. Boss battles are another highlight - no two are quite the same. Then there are the various extras, which keep pulling you back to the game. Visually, Resident Evil 4 has very few equals this generation, thanks to some fantastic attention to detail and brilliant lighting effects. Resident Evil 4 really does have it all - if you're one of the few to check it out yet, make sure you do so.

...


Most Anticipated Game of 2006
5. Dragon Quest VIII (PS2)
4. Shadow of the Colossus (PS2)
3. Kingdom Hearts 2 (PS2)
2. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (PC/Xbox 360)
1. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess (GCN)
D EAD | P Nintendo
PALGN Review: GBA

What else? Link's next adventure, The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess is something almost every gamer wants a taste of, after patiently waiting for the game ever since that first E3 trailer. But, it seems Shigsy and his team are intent on keeping this one under wraps until its good and ready - whenever that may be. We're reasonably confident it will be 2006, at any rate. But, behind Twilight Princess are some other sure-fire gems - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion looks absolutely first rate, on both PC and the Xbox 360. Shadow of the Colossus is fantastic, if reports on the NTSC version are anything to believe, and Dragon Quest VIII and Kingdom Hearts 2 should be a couple of great RPGs. Combine that with the (probable) unveiling of the first Revolution software, and, fingers crossed, the release of that console and the PS3, and we should be in for a great year of gaming.

...


And that's that - PALGN's 2005 awards done and dusted - aside from one thing. The lucky winners of our competition are:

thebigm, who scored Doom 3: Resurrection of Evil on Xbox.
NismoR34, who grabbed a PS2 version of The Incredible Hulk.
mrcivic, who receives Xmen: Legends II on the Xbox.

Congratulations to those winners - and, comiserations to those who tried to pass their email addresses off as a PALGN username. We'll see you all next year for our 2006 awards!

Related Content

Australian Gaming Bargains, 14/04/05
14 Apr, 2005 Not much this week - please tell us if you know of any other good gaming stores.
Australian Gaming Bargains, 31/03/05
31 Mar, 2005 Target have some rather nice prices this week.
Australian Gaming Bargains, 24/03/05
24 Mar, 2005 Easter related bargains! ...Well, not really.
54 Comments
6 years ago
You guys have great taste! Congrats on a fantastic list. And congrats to all the winners! I was especially pleased to see a certain user starting with N taking away one very sweet prize... nice. icon_wink.gif
6 years ago
^ Agreed, nice choices fellow PalGNers. And it's good to see some actuall real members win! Congrats thebigm,Nismo and mr civic
6 years ago
I have to say, I like this list better than the staff one icon_razz.gif

Congrats to the winners - good to see active users winning for a chance.
6 years ago
Nice list, good to see regulars are winners this time icon_lol.gif where did all the girls go? (Or don't they play games?(Ok, we have at least one girl gamer here but where are rest))
6 years ago
nice lists guys, nothing too surprising (well, nothing surprising for the #1's, few surprises in the 2-5 slots though).

congratulations to the winners too, great to see 3 names i recognise icon_smile.gif
6 years ago
Nick wrote
I like this list better than the staff one.
Have to agree, but it's hard not to question how the Playstation 2 version of Resident Evil 4 beat out God Of War and Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater considering how many people bagged this version in another thread.
6 years ago
Thanks for the prize and compliments, and also congratulations to both Nismo and Civ.

Pretty good list I must say, with nothing really standing out (in the sense that it's radically different) on that I would disagree with.
6 years ago
ZNMS wrote
Nick wrote
I like this list better than the staff one.
Have to agree, but it's hard not to question how the Playstation 2 version of Resident Evil 4 beat out God Of War and Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater considering how many people bagged this version in another thread.
Honestly, wtf. Res Evil 4 Ps2 was nothing compared to God of War and MGS3. Sure, it deserves the overall game of the year, but thats because the GCN version provides a much better version.

I actually just got back from buying Res Evil 4 GCN from JB Hi Fi. First impressions: case is in good condition, never been used, A++++ seller. insurance $2 extra. owner too tired to play when bought.
6 years ago
Neat jobs guy for winning the Game(s).

As for the list... As expected.

EDIT ^ How much u get RE 4 for Mitchacho?? I know got mine for $45.
6 years ago
I'm so sick of hearing of RE4.
6 years ago
Pity it's such a brilliant game.
6 years ago
I won I won! icon_biggrin.gif

I must say there were quite a few hard choices there. I voted for Splinter Cell on Xbox for GOTY as I've already got the PC version of Half-Life 2.

And thanks goes to PALGN and the sponsors for the goodies. Cheers. icon_y1.gif
6 years ago
Yep, thanks from me to PALGN/sponsers as well for letting me win something for once. Rarely happens. icon_wink.gif
Congratulations to the other two people as well, both of whom have been long time friends. History unite, or something.

As for the article in general, how the hell can God of War be voted as the second PS2 game of the year and MGS 3 in third, only to have God of War completely non-existant in the overall awards and MGS 3 in there? How does that work exactly?

Well I guess it doesn't matter considering MGS 3 **** all over God of War anyway. *cough*
6 years ago
Spanca wrote
I'm so sick of hearing of RE4.
Just buy it already! icon_razz.gif


NismoR34 wrote
As for the article in general, how the hell can God of War be voted as the second PS2 game of the year and MGS 3 in third, only to have God of War completely non-existant in the overall awards and MGS 3 in there? How does that work exactly?
Because there was a seperate vote for an overall GOTY. If say 50 people put MGS3 as their PS2 GOTY and as their overall GOTY, but at the same time 100 others were putting GoW as their PS2 choice and say RE4 as their GOTY then GoW would be higher in the PS2 rankings, but lower on the overall one. It's a flawed system in that respect, but there's no other (better) way of doing it really.
6 years ago
^ Yes sir icon_razz.gif

I really will buy it... soon... maybe.
6 years ago
Well done guys, as Obsolete said....it's nice to see names you recognise!!!
6 years ago
Chris wrote
Because there was a seperate vote for an overall GOTY. If say 50 people put MGS3 as their PS2 GOTY and as their overall GOTY, but at the same time 100 others were putting GoW as their PS2 choice and say RE4 as their GOTY then GoW would be higher in the PS2 rankings, but lower on the overall one. It's a flawed system in that respect, but there's no other (better) way of doing it really.
so was there any way of distinguishing RE4 GC GOTY votes from RE4 PS2 votes?
6 years ago
Heya, congrats to the 3 prize winners, and yes it's nice to see 3 names you recognize for once! I like this list more than the staff GOTY, it seems more right. FEAR takes PC GOTY, which is good.
6 years ago
Grand job on this Brendy babes - can honestly say I agree with almost all of the choices there. One question though chap: why is F.E.A.R an oxymoron? I'm probably missing it, but I'm confuzzled. :S
6 years ago
Chris-Leigh wrote
why is F.E.A.R an oxymoron? I'm probably missing it, but I'm confuzzled. :S
First Encounter Assault Recon, actually the first two words could count as Recon as well. In Recon you're not suppose to let the enemy know you're there, while Assault is pretty much kill everything.
6 years ago
depends if you read it as FEA - R or FE - AR.

the latter is somewhat oxymoronic, but the former is ok.
ie: at the first encounter of an assault, recon is established.

however, the game is geared more towards action than stealth (though still somewhat possible) so in this terms it's also oxymoronic.

at the end of the day though, it's just a gimmicky name.
6 years ago
Nice list, congratulations to the winners.
6 years ago
838 La wrote
Neat jobs guy for winning the Game(s).

As for the list... As expected.

EDIT ^ How much u get RE 4 for Mitchacho?? I know got mine for $45.
i hate you. $90.
6 years ago
How did you manage $45? icon_neutral.gif
Add Comment
Like this feature?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/PH

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
Currently Popular on PALGN
My most memorable PALGN reviews
Gamers love nostaligia and lists.
Nintendo Store Update - 10/02/12
And that's the end of that chapter!
Final Fantasy XIII-2 Review
Oh good, it's not an excuse to play dress ups.
Soul Calibur V Review
The burning soul will never extinguish!
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.