Home
Twitter
RSS
Newsletter
Matt Keller
09 Apr, 2007

Fight Night Round 3 Review

PS3 Review | Comeback fight?
Over the years, the sport of boxing has had very few quality video game translations. Things began to turn around for the pugilistic arts in 2004, when EA Sports scrapped its button-mashing Knockout Kings series in favour of a stick-based system in the new Fight Night franchise. While it wasn’t the first game to incorporate this style of fighting (that honour goes to Sega’s Title Fight), it really blew other boxing games away with its unprecedented level of control over your fighter. Fight Night Round 2 followed a year later, adding a brutal haymaker system, new commentators and an improved career mode. Last year, Fight Night Round 3 debuted on the new generation of consoles, with extremely impressive (if a little stiff) graphics – though the gameplay did take a couple of steps back. A year later, EA Sports has released a new version of Fight Night Round 3 for the PlayStation 3, but are a few extra features and improved graphics enough?

The jump in visuals shown by Fight Night Round 3 from the Xbox to the Xbox 360 was a real indicator of just what the new consoles are capable of. With an extra year of development time, EA Chicago has managed to squeeze even more detail into the fighters, with the PlayStation 3 version of the game featuring far more detailed skin texturing – you can even see the veins popping out of your fighters’ arms. The boxing arenas have more detail, especially with lighting, giving the sense of spectacle that some feel might have been lacking in the previous versions of the game. The game still runs at a solid frame rate with no noticeable slowdown present.

The other major feature that’s new in the PlayStation 3 version of the game is the Get in the Ring mode. The 360 version of Fight Night Round 3 featured a mini-game after the execution of a special punch – the punchee’s view would go into first person mode, and they would have to blow each blow that their opponent threw, or face eating the canvas. The PS3 version takes this a step further by allowing you to play a full match in first person view, and it adds almost feels like a whole new game. Players must now be more mindful of their ring position, and taking damage will now start to close your fighter’s eyes, making it harder to see blows coming from your opponent. It does seem to make defensive play a bit easier, which lead to our matches lasting a little longer than they had in the regular game mode. All game modes can be played in this feature, which is quite handy – a split screen mode is available for playing against your friends too.

They call this one 'The Fish.'

They call this one 'The Fish.'
Close
To be honest, those two features are all that the new version of Fight Night Round 3 has over the one we all played a year ago. All of the other features from the Xbox 360 version of the game are featured – classic matches, career mode, ESPN integration and online play, so nothing has been lost in translation. The PS3 version of the game does however features the same problems as the previous version, like the robotic, old-gen animation, crappy career mode progression, repetitive commentary, small selection of menu music and obtrusive in-game advertising – and then adds a few of its own.

Arguably the greatest problem with the PS3 version of Fight Night is the increased load times. Load times were not a problem in the 360 game, but now you’re looking at a minute just to get to the first menu. The time it takes from boot up to actually playing a game is closer to 3 minutes. EA has the option to allow for hard drive installations to reduce load times, but have not taken it, and the result is just absurd. The create-a-fighter mode is practically ruined by the sheer amount of time it takes one to create their pugilist, thanks to the game having to load up each and every piece of apparel.

DRAGO!!!

DRAGO!!!
Close
One of the many issues that arise when deciding between an Xbox 360 version of a game and the PS3 version of the game is rumble. For many games, it’s just a minor issue, but for Fight Night Round 3, rumble really adds to the experience – but it’s one of those things that you don’t notice until it’s gone. Playing the new Get in the Ring mode without rumble cheapens any attempt at immersion, and while playing regularly, it makes it harder to pick the timing for the stunner punches. Combined with the flimsy feeling of SIXAXIS, it really makes the Xbox 360 version seem more appealing.

Fight Night Round 3 is still a good game at heart, but the excessive loading times can be quite off putting. It might come across as a better game to someone who hasn’t played earlier games in the series or the 360 version last year. However, if you played the game last March, you’ll quickly discover all of the old problems, plus new ones that really can’t be offset the new features, regardless of how good they are.
The Score
Fight Night Round 3 for the PS3 has the same old problems and a bunch of new ones - and a few scant extra features just aren't enough to tip the balance.
Looking to buy this game right now? PALGN recommends www.Play-Asia.com.

Related Fight Night Round 3 Content

Fight Night Round 3 images enter the ring
10 Oct, 2006 A year late but who's counting?
E3 2005: Fight Night 3 set for the Playstation 3
17 May, 2005 That's right, we've also got the first image.
Fight Night Round 3 Review
30 Mar, 2006 Nice face, shame about the legs.
4 Comments
4 years ago
Great. This was another PS3 launch title i had my eyes set on. It just amazes me that a year later after the 360 release, the game actually manages to become worse. Sony need to start lifting the quality of their multi0platform titles, of which there are plenty.
4 years ago
the doag wrote
Great. This was another PS3 launch title i had my eyes set on. It just amazes me that a year later after the 360 release, the game actually manages to become worse. Sony need to start lifting the quality of their multi0platform titles, of which there are plenty.
It's not Sony's fault that EA are putting out half-assed ports.
Anyway I didn't see any comments about the game being worse? He said the loading times are longer but the visuals have been improved and the first-person mode is a good addition.
4 years ago
fatpizza wrote
Anyway I didn't see any comments about the game being worse?
Well the last 2 paragraphs in the review say a number of times that the 360 version *could* be better depending on the person playing the game.

- "Combined with the flimsy feeling of SIXAXIS, it really makes the Xbox 360 version seem more appealing." - when talking about rumble.
- "It might come across as a better game to someone who hasn’t played earlier games in the series or the 360 version last year." - generally speaking.

I guess it makes enough sense too as the game is a year old and is hardly better. The 360 versions is 'better' because it's been around for that long while the PS3 version is dated and should have been much better. Hearing about the load times is especially disappointing. I've been playing it on the 360 the last week and the load times there are bothering me a lot already!
4 years ago
I never cared for rumble and the load times are not that bad, so the bad points in this review aren't anything I'm concerned about. It only takes about 10 seconds of loading in-between fights on my PS3. Other than that, loading times in career mode could be considered annoying but only because career mode itself is such a repetitive experience (Sign contract, train, fight, repeat).

The main appeal is online play which is great, I don't experience any lag.
Add Comment
Like this review?
Share it with this tiny url: http://palg.nu/GQ

N4G : News for Gamers         Twitter This!

Digg!     Stumble This!

| More
  Pre-order or buy:
    PALGN recommends: www.Play-Asia.com

Australian Release Date:
  Out Now
European Release Date:
  Out Now
Publisher:
  EA Sports
Developer:
  EA Canada
Players:
  1-2

Extra:
Online Play

Read more...
Currently Popular on PALGN
Final Fantasy XIII-2 Review
Oh good, it's not an excuse to play dress ups.
Soul Calibur V Review
The burning soul will never extinguish!
Australian Gaming Bargains - 08/12/11
'Tis the season to be bargaining.
Neverdead Review
Never quite makes it.
Nintendo Store Update - 03/02/12
Going sky high once more.